LEWISBURG, W.Va. (WVDN) – A Greenbrier County Grand Jury met this week and handed up its indictments to the Greenbrier County Circuit Court for the June 2023 term.
Among those indicted were Cynthia Justice and Mitch McCoy, both of Renick, who are charged with helping Ron McMillion dispose of the body of Dee Ann Keene.
Justice and McCoy are charged with one count each of accessory after the fact to murder and concealment of a deceased human body. According to the indictment, on Feb. 28, 2014, Justice and McCoy assisted McMillion by transporting Keene’s body in a vehicle to an unknown location and “burying or otherwise disposing of said body in a secrete manner.” The indictment further states that Justice and McCoy “did so with the knowledge that Dee Ann Keene had been unlawfully killed.”
Keene was last seen at McMillion’s residence on Feb. 28, 2014, and declared missing on March 4, 2014. McMillion was arrested for her murder on Feb. 14 of this year. McMillion remains in Southern Regional Jail as a pretrial felon, being held without bond.
As of press time, neither Justice or McCoy are shown as being in custody. Keene’s body has never been found.
Judge Jennifer Dent’s arraignments will be held on June 21 at 9 a.m., and Judge Robert Richardson’s arraignments will be held on June 21 at 1 p.m.
The following individuals were indicted. They have not been found guilty and are presumed innocent until proven otherwise.
Kayla Anderson, Ronceverte, 36, three counts forgery of a credit card;
Robert Lee Arbaugh, Asbury, 51, delivery of a controlled substance, fentanyl;
Bobby Milton Bennett, Quinwood, 27, breaking and entering, grand larceny;
Robbie Gale Butler, Crawley, 42, two counts delivery of a controlled substance, fentanyl;
Hayley R. Casto, White Sulphur Springs, 36, fraudulent use of an access device, conspiracy to commit fraudulent use of an access device;
Diana Rebecca Cook, Hinton, 41, grand larceny;
Gavin Michael Doss, 29, Lewisburg, prohibited person in possession of a firearm (two counts), reckless fleeing from an officer;
Chelsey Leann Fowler, Union, 24, embezzlement;
Traci Diane Gardner, Crawley, 56, fleeing from an officer while under the influence of alcohol, obstructing an officer;
Shawn Gill, Lewisburg, 43, reckless fleeing from an officer, fleeing from an officer while under the influence of a controlled substance;
Brittany Nicole Gray, Lewisburg, 31, delivery of a controlled substance, methamphetamine (two counts); delivery of a controlled substance, fentanyl (two counts);
Jeffrey Lee Hanna, Renick, 49, grand larceny;
Douglas Kirwan Hedrick, Williamsburg, 39, grand larceny, petit larceny;
Joseph D. Herndon, Orient Hill, 30, reckless fleeing from an officer;
Jeffrey Shane Justice, Renick, 32, forgery of a title;
Cynthia Justice, Renick, 54, accessory after the fact to murder, concealment of a deceased human body;
Brandon G. Keeney, Frankford, 35, reckless fleeing from an officer;
Clinton Dale Kyle, Crawley, 40, driving revoked for DUI, third offense;
Chad Lee Lamp, Martinsburg, 41, possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance, fentanyl; possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance, heroin;
Vesper Ray Lewis, Frankford, 45, attempt to commit burglary, destruction of property, domestic assault;
Edward Lee Lewis, Lewisburg, 55, false report concerning bomb or other explosive device;
Johnny Edward Lind; Lewisburg, 34, malicious wounding, wanton endangerment involving a firearm;
Bradley Ivan Linton, Alderson, 25, possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance, fentanyl; gross child neglect resulting in substantial risk of serious bodily injury or death (two counts); prohibited person in possession of a firearm (two counts);
Isaiah Bridger Lore, Crawley, 24, cruelty to animals;
Taylor Lorian Lowe, Alderson, 50, forgery, uttering;
Mitch McCoy, Renick, 43, accessory after the fact to murder, concealment of a deceased human body;
Ronald Ray McMillion, 71, Renick, prohibited person in possession of a firearm;
Lisa Ann Mullins, Renick, 45, embezzlement;
Curtis Brian Pack, Rainelle, 44, grand larceny;
Carrie Renee Palmer, Alderson, 46, delivery of a controlled substance, fentanyl; delivery of a controlled substance, methamphetamine;
Matthew Pennington, Hot Springs, Va., 41, prohibited person in possession of a firearm, brandishing a deadly weapon;
Tina Marie Rataiczak, Hillsboro, 47, grand larceny;
Abigail E. Richmond, White Sulphur Springs, 23, breaking and entering, grand larceny;
Steven Austin Richmond, Hinton, 33, grand larceny;
Jimmy Rush, Rupert, 27, reckless fleeing from an officer, fleeing from an officer causing death, driving in an impaired state causing death;
Harold Ray Salmons, Rupert, 47, failure to register as a sex offender or provide notice of registration changes (two counts);
Brodey Matthew Sheppard, Lewisburg, 29, breaking and entering, grand larceny, fraudulent use of an access device (two counts);
Andrae C. Simmons Jr., Princeton, 36, possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance, fentanyl; possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance, methamphetamine;
Gaspor Enon Sims, Smoot, 38, sexual assault in the third degree; incest; sexual abuse by a parent, guardian, custodian or person in trust to a child (two counts); sexual abuse in the first degree;
James Howard Smith Sr., Frankford, 57, failure to register as a sex offender or provide notice of registration changes;
Amber Nicole Spangler, Clifton Forge, Va., 47, failure to render aid;
Ashley Jaine Stuart, Rainelle, 24, forgery of a public record;
Erik Benjamin Stull, Ronceverte, 30, failure to register as a sex offender or provide notice of registration changes (two counts);
Colin Wayne Sturgell, Clintonville, 43, destruction of property, petit larceny;
Joseph Michael Thomas, Rainelle, 33, breaking and entering;
Hunter Ross Thompson, Talcott, 25, robbery in the second degree;
Jason Samuel Toney, Ronceverte, 45, breaking and entering, grand larceny;
Joshua Wiley, Lewisburg, 38, prohibited person in possession of a firearm;
Nathan Forrest Wilson, Alderson, 33, delivery a controlled substance, methamphetamine (two counts); delivery of a controlled substance, methamphetamine, to a person in custody; gross child neglect resulting in substantial risk of serious bodily injury or death;
Amanda Wright, White Sulphur Springs, 41, fraudulent use of an access device, conspiracy to commit fraudulent use of an access device.
